Interesting piece by Roger Cohen in the Sunday NY Times that discusses some of the cultural differences between the U.S. and Europe. Cohen begins by talking about an Italian architect who was recently wounded while working in Afghanistan:
… his presence in the western city of Herat was somehow comforting, even if what had happened to him was not. Each country has its talents; Italy has a talent for beauty. This attribute is not easily measurable: no online graphic can illustrate it. Still, it is palpable, and an architect’s cultural work in an ancient Afghan town seemed to me part of a particular Italian disposition.
After that opening, the article goes on to both lament that these “particularities” of culture are becoming less important in the modern world, and at the same time to suggest that European nations need to be better prepared to deal with change.
French youth … spent weeks in the street to protest and ultimately overturn a law that would have given them jobs at the price of losing existing guarantees against the abrupt termination of employment. The proposal smacked too much of “precariousness” for the French. … They opted, in short, for security over risk, a choice many Americans find puzzling.
Italians, too, are unhappy with the advance of “precariousness.” This is still a society where a central goal is to be “sistemato” — secured in a paid position, preferably not too labor intensive, that can be held for life and, if possible, passed on to the children.
Such stasis is anathema to Americans, for whom risk, movement and personal ambition are fundamental. …Â The United States is about the endless possibility of self-reinvention through hard work. It is inseparable from change.
Cohen’s back-and-forth essay is understandable. Change is inevitable, globalization is here to stay, and the cultural tendency of Americans to move, strive, and take chances is in synch with these times. But still. Anyone who has ever enjoyed a meal in a French bistro or whiled away an afternoon in a sunny Italian cafe knows the appreciation that those cultures have for life’s little pleasures and likely understands their reluctance to give up even some of their security or pace of life in the name of economic efficiency. Is there a happy medium?
Â