Redesigning the pilgrimage to Mecca

how we live — By Bob Riel on December 21, 2007 at 7:20 am

The annual Islamic pilgrimage to the Saudi cities of Mecca and Medina is a huge and often chaotic event. Several million Muslims from around the world make the annual pilgrimage, and the crush of people has resulted in numerous tragedies and thousands of deaths. So this year the government of Saudi Arabia hired a team of German engineers to redesign the public walkways and the daily schedule in an effort to head off future disasters. Newsweek magazine reports:

German engineer Dirk Serwill had one reaction when presented with his most recent assignment: “Oh, my God.” God would actually play quite a prominent role in the project. Serwill was part of a team of German engineers hired last year by Saudi Arabia to help revamp the hajj, the annual Islamic pilgrimage, taking place this month, that draws millions to the holy cities of Mecca and Medina.

The recent explosion in the number of pilgrims—from 1.5 million in 1996 to almost 4 million in 2006—has resulted in thousands of deaths in recent years. One engineer described it as “the biggest pedestrian problem in the world”—trying to fit millions of people speaking dozens of languages from 100 different countries into three square kilometers.

The crux of the problem is three ancient pillars in the Mina Valley, which pilgrims are required to stone as a symbol of the Devil. Serwill watches on his video monitor as thousands of pilgrims surround the site, a scene he compares to the spin cycle of a washing machine, “pushing and fighting their way to the pillars,” he says. Generally, three to four people can fit into one square meter; in Mecca, 10 fit in that space.

“You don’t find these levels of density among humans anywhere else—only among rats,” says Habib Zein Al-Abideen, the Saudi deputy minister of Municipal and Rural Affairs and head of the kingdom’s hajj-related construction. Under such conditions, pilgrims are exposed to pressure equivalent to more than a ton—similar to the weight of a small car.

Working mainly off videos and aerial photographs, the engineers employed cutting-edge computer software to digitally map pilgrim flows so that they could pinpoint the exact moments when disasters have broken out in the past. They used the latest theories in “panic studies” to understand how people react when forced into “escape mode”—much of it applied from rock concerts and football games.

Based on these studies, the engineers redesigned the entire hajj process by creating a network of one-way streets, circumscribed plazas, overflow areas and emergency escape routes—applying a strict structure to what has historically been haphazard and chaotic. They also organized what might be the most complex schedule ever attempted, coordinating time slots for 30,000 different groups of 100 pilgrims each.